Church Digital

For churches · Comparison

Church Digital vs ReachRight

ReachRight is a managed church-website provider with transparent monthly pricing and no setup fee on the 12-month plan. On paper, the monthly tier sits right alongside Church Digital's website plan. The differences show up around design approach and contract terms. This page puts the two next to each other so the trade-offs are visible.

Get my free homepage demo →See pricing →

Side by side

Church Digital and ReachRight, line by line.

Pricing and terms are taken from each vendor’s publicly listed pages. If anything looks stale, point it out and we’ll update it.

 Church DigitalReachRight
Monthly$120–$297/mo, published$97/mo (web only); bundles $397–$797/mo
Setup feeNone$2,000 waived with 12-month
ContractNo contract — cancel anytime12-month minimum
Who builds itWe do — custom design, built for youPlatform build (template/custom mix)
Custom designCustomMixed
If you leaveCancel anytime; your domain and content stay yoursVendor-hosted — the site does not come with you
SupportA human replies within 1 business day — published SLAVendor support from their team

Positioning

Looking for a ReachRight alternative for your church website?

ReachRight is a church-focused agency that bundles website hosting with digital marketing services — Google Ads management (especially the $10,000/month Google Ad Grant for nonprofits) at $397/mo, Local SEO at $297/mo, and Sermon Sling clip production starting at $550/mo. Their pricing is unusually transparent for an agency — each service is listed openly. The website is the foundation, but the real strategic angle is bundling everything one team for churches that want a single partner across web, ads, and SEO.

Who they're built for: churches with the appetite and budget to run active digital marketing — Google Ad Grant in particular — and that want a single team handling both the website and the campaigns running against it. The website-only tier ($97/mo) exists, but the deeper value is when you take the bundled marketing services alongside it.

Who they're not really built for: churches that just want a strong website and have no plans to run paid ads or SEO retainers. If you're paying for the website-only tier, you're paying for an agency-shape provider without leveraging the agency shape — at which point a more focused website-only provider tends to be a cleaner fit.

Cost

The actual cost math.

Numbers are current as of early 2026. Pricing moves — confirm rates with the vendor before you commit.

ReachRight's website-only plan is published at $97/mo with a $2,000 setup fee that is waived on the 12-month commitment, as listed on reachrightstudios.com/pricing on 2026-05-12. On the 12-month plan, year one is $1,164 and year two is $1,164, for a two-year total of $2,328. Skip the commitment and the $2,000 setup adds to year one.

The other ReachRight services are published transparently too: Local SEO at $297/mo (with a $1,500 setup waived on the 12-month plan), Google Ad Grant management at $397/mo (with a $2,000 setup waived on the 12-month plan), and Sermon Sling starting at $550/mo for one weekly clip. The bundles are Website + Local SEO at $397/mo and Website + Local SEO + Google Ad Grant at $797/mo. If you take the full bundle, two-year cost lands near $19,128 — that is the apples-to-apples figure for a one-vendor-for-web-and-marketing arrangement.

Church Digital's website plan has no setup fee and no contract, and the flat monthly rate lands close to ReachRight's website-only tier over two years — see our current pricing for the numbers to run your own math. The split shows up when you add marketing services: ReachRight bundles them on one bill, Church Digital offers advertising as its own flat monthly plan, and you would source SEO retainers from a specialist separately.

What is and isn't included: ReachRight bundles hosting, routine content updates, and a templated-or-customized design built on their platform. Domain registration is separate. Ad spend is separate from ad management fees. Church Digital includes hosting, custom design, and routine content updates on the website plan; ad spend and any SEO retainers would be sourced separately. If you genuinely want one vendor for both, ReachRight has the integrated offering at published prices; if you'd rather buy ads and SEO from a specialist on their own merits, the website-only comparison is what matters.

Feature comparison

Feature comparison, with the tradeoffs.

Five places where the two providers actually differ — not a checklist of features, but how each one handles the work in practice.

Design and customization

ReachRight

ReachRight builds on a structured platform with church-specific layouts. The design feels considered and church-appropriate, but the structure tends to feel more SaaS-templated than fully custom — many ReachRight sites share recognizable layout patterns. You can customize colors, photography, and content within their framework.

Church Digital

Church Digital starts from a blank canvas for each church. There is no shared platform layout to start from. The design process is longer than picking a layout, but the result does not visually overlap with other sites we have built.

If you want the marketing-services bundle, the templated-platform tradeoff is worth it. If you only want the website piece, the customization gap is more visible.

Updates and content management

ReachRight

ReachRight includes routine content updates in the monthly plan. The same email-the-team workflow as most managed vendors. Their team has worked with enough churches to handle the typical request set quickly.

Church Digital

Church Digital covers the same shape — sermons, events, photo refreshes, staff and ministry pages — by email or ticket, handled for you as part of the flat monthly plan.

On this dimension the two are roughly equivalent. The difference is what the church team prefers to outsource versus run themselves.

Performance and SEO basics

ReachRight

ReachRight's SEO and marketing focus shows up here — sites are built with reasonable on-page SEO discipline, structured for indexability, and the agency has experience tuning churches for local search. Page speed is acceptable for the templated platform but not industry-leading.

Church Digital

Church Digital builds on a modern stack (Next.js) with structured data, optimized images, and Core Web Vitals baked in by default. Sites tend to score in the green on Core Web Vitals without needing additional optimization work.

ReachRight wins on actively managed SEO work if you take the retainer. Church Digital wins on the technical performance baseline of the site itself.

Integrations (giving, ChMS, calendaring)

ReachRight

ReachRight handles the standard church-integration list — Planning Center, Tithe.ly, Subsplash, embedded video, calendaring. They have agency experience setting these up, which is helpful if your church is brand new to a tool.

Church Digital

Church Digital embeds the same standard set — Planning Center, Tithe.ly, Pushpay, RightNow Media, sermon players. The integration list is whatever the church already uses, dropped into the custom design.

Both cover the common stack. ReachRight has more hand-holding if you also need help picking the underlying tools.

Support model and ownership

ReachRight

ReachRight is vendor-managed: site lives on their platform. If you leave at the end of the 12-month term, the site does not come with you. Support is from their team via email and ticket, with account management proportional to which services you have bundled.

Church Digital

Church Digital is also fully managed, but with no contract — flat published monthly, cancel anytime. Build is on a modern stack. Support is from a small team, typically the same person across the engagement.

The contract split is the clearest functional difference between the two — everything else is degrees on a spectrum.

Common scenarios

Common scenarios, and how each one tends to land.

Concrete church profiles, the honest fit for each provider, and which way each one leans.

Church already approved for the Google Ad Grant and wants to actually use the full $10,000/month allowance.

ReachRight

ReachRight is built for this. Ad Grant management is one of their core services and bundling it with the website team creates real workflow advantages.

Church Digital

Church Digital's advertising plan runs Google and social ads at a flat monthly, but dedicated Google Ad Grant management is ReachRight's specialty — you would confirm Ad Grant scope with us first.

Leans toward ReachRight

Church that wants a website that looks visually distinctive — clearly not a "church website template".

ReachRight

ReachRight can customize within their platform, but the structure reads as agency-templated. A truly custom feel is harder to achieve.

Church Digital

Church Digital starts from a blank page each time. The visual outcome is shaped by the specific church rather than a platform layout.

Leans toward Church Digital

Church with a part-time communications director who can handle weekly updates if given the tools.

ReachRight

ReachRight is built around the managed-service model. You can request updates, but the platform is not designed for the church to self-publish at speed.

Church Digital

Church Digital handles routine updates as part of the flat monthly plan, so the communications director can hand off site maintenance — or keep sending updates in as often as they like, with no per-update billing.

Leans toward Church Digital

Larger church running active SEO and ads campaigns alongside the website, wants one vendor accountable for the whole funnel.

ReachRight

ReachRight is the cleaner fit here. The integrated bundle means one team owns the whole picture rather than coordination across vendors.

Church Digital

Church Digital covers the website and advertising at flat monthlies; an SEO retainer would come from a separate specialist. Fewer bills than fully à la carte, but not one team for everything.

Leans toward ReachRight

Switching

Switching from ReachRight: what it actually involves.

Switching off ReachRight involves the same kind of work as switching off any vendor-managed platform: you export the content manually (copy, images, sermon archive, staff and ministry pages), and the new build re-enters it. The site itself is not portable to a new host; the assets are. For a typical church website the content set is small enough that this is a manageable lift inside a normal redesign timeline.

If you have bundled marketing services with ReachRight, the bigger migration question is who picks up the Google Ads account, the SEO retainer, and any custom campaign tracking. The website hand-off is the easy part; the ads-and-SEO continuity is where you want to plan carefully so paid traffic does not drop during the gap.

Domain DNS and email setup follow the same playbook as any vendor switch. Confirm any term-remaining or auto-renewal language in writing before you start the conversation about leaving.

Honest fit

When each one is the right pick.

Pick ReachRight when

When ReachRight is the better fit

  • You want a familiar, longstanding managed church-website vendor.
  • You like the idea of bundling ads and SEO services with the same team that runs your website.
  • You are comfortable with a vendor-managed site that lives on their platform long-term.

Pick Church Digital when

When Church Digital is the better fit

  • You want a fully custom homepage and interior design rather than a templated layout.
  • It matters that there is no contract — flat monthly, cancel anytime.
  • You would rather hire ads and SEO separately, on their own merits, instead of bundled.

Bottom line

The bottom line.

Choose ReachRight when you want a single agency for website, Google Ads, and SEO — especially if you're running the $10,000/month Google Ad Grant and want a team that does this every day. Choose Church Digital when you want a fully custom design at a flat published monthly with no contract — cancel anytime. The monthlies land in a similar range. The split is whether you want a bundled marketing partner or a focused website partner.

Get my free homepage demo →Compare plans →

What they don't tell you

VendorSetup fee
ReachRight$2,000 setup fee*
Clover Sites~$1,000 build fee
Church Plant Media$499 setup fee
Church Digital$0, ever

*waived only with a 12-month contract

the $29/month sites aren't $29/month

Useful next reads

Keep reading on ReachRight and the alternatives.

Two or three picks from our church insights and tools — sized for someone comparing vendors, not someone who already signed.

Insight

Read the 2026 church website cost breakdown

A real breakdown across DIY, mid-tier subscriptions, and custom-managed plans.

Insight

Read: online giving platforms compared in 2026

Tithe.ly, Pushpay, Subsplash, Givelify, and Planning Center — fees, fit, and how each one connects to your website.

Pillar

Read: online giving for churches — overview

The plain-language overview of how online giving works for churches — start here before the head-to-head comparison.

Want a second pair of eyes on your current site?

Send the URL and we’ll record a 5-minute review through the eyes of a first-time guest. No pitch, no obligation.

Get my free homepage demo →Back to home