Church Digital

For churches · Online giving

Pushpay alternatives for churches, with the fees each one publishes

Fees checked October 22, 2026 · no vendor paid to be listed

Pushpay is a giving platform aimed at larger churches. If you are weighing it against something simpler or cheaper, the hard part is that Pushpay does not publish a price. Here is what Pushpay does publish, six alternatives that list their fees, and how to choose between them.

What it looks like

A finished church site, built and kept current for you

$90 a month for as long as you stay (regular $120). No setup fee. Nothing to pay until your site is live.

Custom design, hosting and every update by email. No contract, and a real person replies within one business day.

See the plan and start →

Crystal Coast Church of the Nazarene homepage on a computer, built by Church Digital
Crystal Coast Church of the Nazarene homepage on a phone
Crystal Coast Church of the Nazarene (NC): a real client site, live today.

Pushpay itself

What Pushpay publishes about its pricing

Here is what its pricing page said on October 22, 2026. Processing rates are quoted, not published. Pushpay bills a subscription on top, paid monthly or annually by automatic ACH. No setup fees.

Pricing is not published and comes through a sales demo. Contracts run 1, 2 or 3 years, and cancelling early means paying the balance of the contract. That is the usual reason a small church looks elsewhere: the cost is not visible until after a sales conversation.

Plenty of churches use it. Pushpay was the destination for 20 of the 1,298 working giving links in our 2026 study (full data at /research). It suits a larger church with a staff member who will use its donor tools.

The alternatives

Six Pushpay alternatives that publish their fees

Each figure below is the vendor's own, read on its pricing or help page on October 22, 2026. Fees change, so confirm on the vendor's site before you switch. No vendor paid to be listed.

  • Tithe.ly

    Monthly fee
    $0 for giving (text giving $19/mo add-on)
    Fees as published
    Free giving plan: no monthly fee, setup fee or contract. You pay card processing of 2.9% + $0.30 per gift.
    The trade-off
    The free plan covers giving only. Text giving costs $19/mo on that plan, and the Tithe.ly app, website and church management tools are separate paid plans.
  • Planning Center Giving

    Monthly fee
    $0 to $239/mo by donation volume
    Fees as published
    Free up to 10 donations/mo, then tiered from $15/mo to $239/mo by donation count; cards 2.15% + $0.30, ACH a flat $0.30.
    The trade-off
    The monthly fee rises with the number of donations, not their size: free up to 10 a month, then $15/mo for up to 75, rising to $239/mo for unlimited.
  • Givelify

    Monthly fee
    $0
    Fees as published
    No monthly fee; 2.9% + $0.30 per donation.
    The trade-off
    Givelify publishes no bank (ACH) rate, so every published fee is a card fee: 2.9% + $0.30, or 3.5% + $0.30 on Amex. Its help center describes giving through Givelify's own mobile app.
  • Subsplash Giving

    Monthly fee
    $0 (giving only)
    Fees as published
    No monthly fee for giving; cards 2.99% + $0.30 (2.3% + $0.30 with an Exclusive Partnership agreement), ACH 1% with no fixed fee.
    The trade-off
    The 2.3% card rate and GrowCurve rebates require an Exclusive Partnership agreement. Giving-only and non-exclusive accounts pay 2.99% + $0.30 per card gift.
  • Vanco

    Monthly fee
    $0/mo (Grow, conditional) or $54/mo (Thrive)
    Fees as published
    Grow plan $0/mo if you meet its onboarding conditions ($10/mo otherwise), or Thrive at $54/mo with lower processing rates.
    The trade-off
    Every Grow-plan gift carries a $0.45 fixed fee on top of the percentage ($0.39 on Thrive), and the $0/mo Grow plan carries onboarding conditions.
  • easyTithe

    Monthly fee
    $19 to $75/mo
    Fees as published
    Plans at $19/mo, $49/mo and $75/mo, each with a $10 monthly minimum in processing fees; cards 2.6% to 3% + $0.42 depending on plan.
    The trade-off
    Every plan charges a monthly fee ($19 to $75) on top of per-gift fees of 2.6% to 3% + $0.42 on cards, while most platforms here list $0 a month for giving.

How to choose

How to pick between them

  • You already run Planning Center

    Look at Planning Center Giving first. Gifts land in the same database as your people.

  • You have no monthly budget

    Start with a platform that charges per gift and nothing per month. Tithe.ly and Givelify both list no monthly fee for giving.

  • Most gifts come by bank transfer

    Compare the bank (ACH) line, not only the card line. The bank fee can differ more between platforms than the card fee does.

  • Your members give by text

    Check that text giving is included and what it costs. On some entry plans it is a paid add-on.

  • You want an answer for your own church

    Answer a few questions in the giving picker and it ranks the top 3 for your size, giving volume and church software.

    Open the free giving platform picker →

Free to the church

A giving option with no fees to the church

As of October 22, 2026, zeffy.com/pricing says Zeffy charges no platform fees and covers transaction and credit card fees. Zeffy pays its own costs by asking each donor for an optional tip at checkout, and its site says donors are never forced to tip. Your members will see that tip request, so make a small gift yourself and read the checkout screen the way a member would.

Our disclosure: Church Digital partners with Zeffy. When a church we work with wants online giving with no platform fees, Zeffy is the option we point to, so weigh our view with that in mind. If your church already uses a platform that works, keep it. We connect whichever one you choose.

Switching

Before you leave Pushpay

Our 2026 study of 1,734 small-church websites found a working giving link on 64.2% of sites. A platform switch is an easy moment for a working link to turn into a dead one, so plan the day.

  • Read your contract end date

    Check the term you signed and when it ends before you set a switch date.

  • Export your giving history first

    Download donor records and year-to-date totals so year-end statements are complete.

  • Tell recurring givers twice

    A recurring gift usually has to be set up again on the new platform. Say so from the front and by email, and keep the old page live until most have moved.

  • Change every link on the same day

    The Give button, the footer, the app, the bulletin QR code and the Google listing. An old link sends a giver to a dead page.

Common questions

Questions churches ask

How much does Pushpay cost?
Pushpay does not publish its pricing. Processing rates are quoted, not published. Pushpay bills a subscription on top, paid monthly or annually by automatic ACH. No setup fees. You need a quote from Pushpay to know the cost for your church (pricing page checked October 22, 2026).
What is the best Pushpay alternative for a small church?
It depends on what you already use. A church on Planning Center should look at Planning Center Giving first. A church starting out with no monthly budget can begin on Tithe.ly or Givelify, which list no monthly fee for giving. The giving picker ranks them for your answers.
Is there a free alternative to Pushpay?
Several platforms charge no monthly fee and take a fee from each gift instead. Zeffy charges the church no platform or processing fees and asks donors for an optional tip (zeffy.com/pricing, checked October 22, 2026). Church Digital partners with Zeffy.
Can we switch giving platforms without rebuilding our website?
Yes. The Give button is a link, so it can point to any platform. If we run your site, we change it for you. Most routine updates go live the same business day, and you’ll always hear back within one business day.
Does Church Digital sell giving software?
No. We build and run church websites for $120 a month flat, or $90 a month at the founding rate, and we connect the giving platform you choose.

More comparisons and guides

Giving link check

Send your site and we will check the Give button

A free four-minute review of your homepage, including whether a first-time giver can find the Give button and reach a working giving page on a phone. No pitch, no call required.

Go deeper

Related reading